The Cable: Quality Television, Unlimited Calls to the US & Canada, 2MB High Speed Internet

Connect with WINN FM

Unit C24, The Sands Complex
Newtown Bay Road, Basseterre, St. Kitts, W.I.

Injunction remains as parties await judge's decision

St. Kitts and Nevis (WINN): Justice Darshan Ramdhani has reserved judgment on the application to strike out an injunction to prohibit the governor general from signing off on a proclamation effecting constituency boundaries changes.  Justice Ramdhani said he would need a couple weeks to give his decision, which means in the meantime, the conservatory order prohibiting the governing general remains in effect for that duration.

The High Court on Friday heard arguments from both the respondents and the claimants on whether to strike out the injunction or to grant leave for judicial review of the procedures used in preparing the boundaries changes recommendations. The court session ended late Friday evening; just about 6:05pm. 

Anthony Astaphan, lead counsel representing Prime Minister Dr. Denzil Douglas, one of the respondents in this matter, told WINN FM news after Friday’s hearing that he believes enough was presented to the court to show that leave should not be granted to the claimants for judicial review.  “You heard the judge said he is going to need time to deliver his judgment and that the order he made earlier on will stay enforced for the next 14 days,” Astaphan said. “That will give us the opportunity ….to come back to the court and if necessary, if something arises that requires further intervention of the court, we will come back,” Astaphan said.

He said if the judge rules that the conservatory order is to be discharged, then it’s the end of the matter. “If leave is granted however, the judge may issue another conservatory order. But I tend to doubt he will. I suspect he is going to have to try to attempt to craft another order…I think we said quite a bit today to show the court that we do not believe that leave should be granted,” Astaphan explained.    

The basis of the respondents’ arguments is that the opposition had enough time to object to recommendations of the report before it was presented in parliament and as such the injunction should be struck out. “You can’t have information well in advance of the date of the sitting of the House (of Assembly), sit on it and then when you believe that the report is going to the parliament with the prime minister that you rush to the court and claim that you didn’t know what was going on,” Astaphan said.

Meanwhile, Leader of the People’s Labour Party Dr. Timothy Harris, one of the claimants who filed the injunction, was satisfied with the day’s proceedings and the arguments put forward by their representative lead counsel Douglas Mendez S.C. “We believe that the arguments were convincing, at least for me as a lay person and we await for the judge to give due consideration to the matters that have been put before (the court),” he said. He was pleased that the conservatory order pertaining to the injunction remains. “We are happy that the injunction stays and so the status quo remains until the judge makes a further order,” he said.

Other lead counsels representing the respondents are Mr. Ransford Braham representing the Governor General and Roger Forde representing the Constituency Boundaries Commission and the Attorney General. The court injunction barring the Governor General from acting on the boundaries changes was filed by four Members of the Opposition: Mark Brantley, Shawn Richards, Timothy Harris and Eugene Hamilton on September 9th.   Within days (September 13th) the Attorney General’s Chambers filed a Notice of Application to have it discharged.  Parliament on September 9th passed a resolution stipulating boundary changes based on the constituencies boundaries report. The opposition was absent from that parliamentary session.

Click below to hear full item

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Add comment


Security code
Refresh


Top Local Stories

Most Read - September 2014

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Prev Next

Uncovered, blocked drains in Half Way Tree a concern (Video included)

Friday 3rd October, 2014 Hits:10289

Staff Writer

***UPDATED*** Shooting at Hospital Leaves One Injured, Several Traumatised

Tuesday 23rd September, 2014 Hits:7402

Toni Frederick

Cabinet ministers comment on 31 years of independence

Sunday 14th September, 2014 Hits:4740

Andre Huie

UPDATE: MV Lady Mignonne Capsizes

Friday 12th September, 2014 Hits:4381

Staff Writer

ECCB Management Accused of Autocratic Behavior

Friday 26th September, 2014 Hits:3787

Ken Richards

No Emergency In Emergency Sitting Of Parliament

Wednesday 17th September, 2014 Hits:3545

Ken Richards

Contract Of Police Commissioner Being Renewed

Monday 1st September, 2014 Hits:3410

Ken Richards

Police blotter: Ellia Jeffers remanded, escapee surrenders

Saturday 13th September, 2014 Hits:3358

Staff Writer

First set of Triplets born at JNF in several years

Wednesday 10th September, 2014 Hits:3354

Andre Huie

Commission and AG File Cross Appeal in Boundaries Change Case

Thursday 2nd October, 2014 Hits:3333

Ken Richards

Brantley: Removal of Secession Clause is Matter for the People to Decide

Wednesday 1st October, 2014 Hits:3259

Ken Richards

***UPDATED*** Worker Killed in Accident at Kittitian Hill

Friday 17th October, 2014 Hits:3195

Toni Frederick

Three Caribbean hotels listed on “ten hotels from hell"

Wednesday 10th September, 2014 Hits:3111

Ken Richards





WW Episode 24

LISTEN AGAIN

 - WINN FM Evening News - 31st Oct., 2014

Click below to hear full item

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

 

 

 

- Inside the News - Saturday 25th October, 2014

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

- The Bigger Picture with Ken Richards 26th October, 2014

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

-The Operating Room 28th October, 2014

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.