Opposition Lawmakers win court victory on injunction and judicial review matters
- Published on Monday, 25 November 2013 08:03
- Written by Ken Richards
- Hits: 3159
St. Kitts and Nevis (WINN): The injunction stands and a judicial review on some specific areas of contention will be allowed. That ruling Monday by High Court Judge Darshan Ramdhani, in relation to the constituency boundary changes matter. The Government of St Kitts-Nevis in September filed a legal motion seeking to lift the injunction granted to Opposition lawmakers who are seeking to block proposed changes to constituency boundaries ahead of the next general elections.
The order was against the Governor General – it restrains him from making any proclamation to effect the boundaries changes based on the report of the Constituency Boundaries Commission, that were approved by parliament. Justice Ramdhani, in a 160 page ruling Monday, said if the Governor General was allowed to make the proclamation it would deprive the court of jurisdiction. He also ruled that the respondents have not given any good reason why the judicial review should not proceed. Team Unity Leader Dr Timothy Harris has hailed the judgment as a victory for the opposition.
“So we won today and we hope that the people of St Kitts and Nevis will win every day moving forward,” Dr Harris told WINN FM. Reminded that the opposition lawmakers didn’t have it all their way, because the judge said there was no evidence to back their claim that the Constituency Boundaries Commission acted improperly, the Team Unity leader had this response: “Well, you don’t need everything to win … we won fundamentally what we want, that we believe that to have proceeded with the boundaries report would have done an injustice to the people of St Kitts and Nevis.
And we have the opportunity for the court to hear that substantively at a later date,” Dr Harris said. “For now nothing can happen, and the executive remains stalled in their mad plan, a vicious plan I would add, to undermine the democracy by this government which is illegitimate - that for us is an outstanding victory,” he concluded.
Dr Harris was optimistic that his team will also be successful at the actual judicial review, for which a date has not yet been set. Attorney General Jason Hamilton declined to comment when asked about the court ruling.
Listen to the full report here
Top Local Stories
Most Read - June 2015
WINN FM Evening News - 27th June, 2015
- The Bigger Picture with Ken Richards June 7th, 2015
-The Operating Room - 23rd June, 2015